Back
The Madonna of Humility with the Temptation of Eve
The Cleveland Museum of Art · Holden Collection
Museum

The Madonna of Humility with the Temptation of Eve

c. 1400
Olivuccio di Ciccarello (Italian, Marche, 1360/65–1439) visual detail
ArtistOlivuccio di Ciccarello (Italian, Marche, 1360/65–1439)
View artist →

Market Intelligence

Observed sale facts, comparable evidence, artist index history and modeled research remain separate.

Public evidence
Last known price—0 matched observed sales
Observed median—
Observed sales0
Artist index—
No rights-cleared normalized observed sale is attached to this artwork. No synthetic price history is shown.
Artist index unavailableNo completed public artist-index build exists.Artist-level context is not an artwork valuation.

Comparable Sales

Same-artist public sales ranked by medium, creation year, dimensions and sale recency.

Evidence ranked
No public-rights comparable sales meet the current evidence criteria. RELICT does not fill the table with research-only or licensed-only facts.

Provenance

Public
Provenance

James Jackson Jarves (1884)

Provenance

Mrs. Liberty E. Holden, Cleveland

Source provenance text

James Jackson Jarves (1884) Mrs. Liberty E. Holden, Cleveland

The Cleveland Museum of ArtConfidence 100%

Exhibitions

Public
Source exhibition text

Inaugural Exhibition. The Cleveland Museum of Art, Cleveland, OH (organizer) (co-organizer) (June 6-September 20, 1916). The Twentieth Anniversary Exhibition: The Official Art Exhibit of the Great Lakes Exposition. The Cleveland Museum of Art, Cleveland, OH (organizer) (June 26-October 4, 1936). Gothic Art 1360-1440. The Cleveland Museum of Art, Cleveland, OH (organizer) (August 6-September 15, 1963). Boston Foreign Art Exhibit, 1883, cat. no. 399 The Museum of Metropolitan Art, 1912, cat. no. 12, illus. The Inaugural Exhibition of the Cleveland Museum of Art, The Cleveland Museum of Art, June 6-Sept. 20, 1916, cat. no. 16 The Twentieth Anniversary Exhibition, The Cleveland Museum of Art, 1936, cat. no. 90, pl. XI Gothic Art 1360-1440; The Cleveland Museum of Art, Aug. 8- Sept. 15, 1963, cat. no. 76, illus. p. 185

The Cleveland Museum of ArtConfidence 100%
Related public works

Visual neighbours

Explore catalog →

Sourced Overview Evidence

The Madonna is seated humbly on the ground nursing her child. Saint George and the Archangels Gabriel and Michael kneel nearby, while Christ’s disciples appear radiating from the Madonna’s halo in the form of stars. In contrast with the Virgin’s purity, Eve lies in the lower part of the painting. Coaxed by the serpent, she raises the forbidden fruit to her mouth, thus condemning humankind through her original sin. The juxtaposition of these two images affirms the Incarnation and the role of Christ and the Virgin in the redemption story. The deep scratches on the surface of the panel, especially on the serpent’s face and Eve’s wrist, likely resulted from a zealous Christian’s symbolic attack on the power of evil. The artist, Olivuccio di Ciccarello, is known to have been active in the Marche in central Italy. Little is known of his life except that he was an important and prolific painter in Ancona, where he died. His paintings were formerly attributed to Carlo da Camerino, an apparently nonexistent artist, on the basis of a mistaken reading of his signature on a crucifix.

The Cleveland Museum of ArtConfidence 100%

Evidence state

Observed sales: 0 · Comparable Sales: 0 · Provenance: 2 · Exhibitions: 3.

Place Of OriginShort DescriptionProvenance TextExhibition HistoryCredit Line